Skip to main content

Materials Test designed by AI? (In-Progress)

While watching videos of industrial 3D printing processes, I came upon a 1/2 second "B roll" shot of someone's hands packing what are clearly 3D printed parts into what I believe was "Green Sand" used by the metals casting industry (Red/Brown, superfine, & slightly sticky).  This made me wonder if the tightly packed nature of that casting sand could be a reasonably "available" method of keeping the "As-Printed" dimensions while getting the added properties annealing lends to certain materials.

Regular powders sorta work, but they typically collapse with the model if the polymer collapses.  Plaster of Paris sorta works better than powders but can be REALLY irritating to get out of a model!  "Green Sand" tends to keep it's shape under VERY impressive forces/temperatures while liquid metals are poured through the mold cavities.  It definitely has some promise! (at least in my mind)

Since LLMs(Large Language Models) are all the rage currently, I asked "Gemini 2.5 flash" :  [ design a test for the quoted hypothesis following peer reviewed scientific methodologies "Can "Green Sand" ensure the dimensional stability of 3d printed poly-carbonate parts while annealing at elevated temperatures" ]

Any thoughts or suggestions? (I'm certainly NOT a materials scientist!)

This section is "as pasted from Gemini":

Hypothesis

"Green Sand" will significantly reduce or eliminate dimensional changes (shrinkage, warping, or other deformations) in 3D-printed polycarbonate parts when annealed at elevated temperatures, compared to parts annealed without a supporting medium or with other traditional annealing methods.

Experimental Design

1. Materials

  • 3D Printer: A reliable 3D printer capable of consistently printing polycarbonate (e.g., one with an enclosed build chamber and high-temperature capabilities).

  • Polycarbonate Filament: A consistent brand and type of polycarbonate filament. Ensure it's properly dried before printing.

  • Green Sand: Foundry-grade "Green Sand" (a mixture of silica sand, clay (bentonite), and water).

  • Annealing Oven: A laboratory or industrial oven capable of maintaining precise and stable temperatures up to and beyond the annealing temperature of polycarbonate (typically 120-150°C, but specific to the PC grade).

  • Measurement Tools:

    • High-precision Digital Calipers: For measuring part dimensions before and after annealing ( mm accuracy).

    • Micrometer: For finer measurements if necessary ( mm accuracy).

    • 3D Scanner (Optional but Recommended): For comprehensive dimensional analysis of complex geometries, providing a more complete picture of warping or deformation.

  • Control Media (Optional but Recommended for Comparison):

    • Air (No support): Standard annealing without any support.

    • Granular Salt: A common alternative support medium.

    • Talcum Powder: Another potential alternative.

2. Part Design

Design multiple identical test parts with specific features to monitor dimensional stability.

  • Simple Geometric Shapes: Cubes, rectangles, and cylinders of varying sizes to assess uniform shrinkage.

  • Complex Geometries: Parts with thin walls, overhangs, or intricate features that are prone to warping.

  • Calibration Features: Include specific, easily measurable dimensions (e.g., holes of precise diameter, gaps, lengths, and widths marked at specific points) that can be accurately measured before and after annealing.

  • Orientation Consistency: Design the parts so they can be printed in a consistent orientation across all trials (e.g., flat on the build plate) to minimize print-induced variability.

3. Printing Procedure

  • Standardized Settings: Use consistent print settings for all polycarbonate parts (e.g., layer height, infill density, print speed, nozzle temperature, bed temperature, fan speed).

  • Optimize Print Quality: Ensure high-quality prints with minimal defects for all samples.

  • Number of Samples: Print a sufficient number of identical samples for each experimental group (e.g., 5-10 replicates per group) to ensure statistical significance.

4. Pre-Annealing Measurements

  • Baseline Data: Carefully measure all pre-defined dimensions of each 3D-printed part using calipers or a 3D scanner.

  • Record Data: Record all measurements meticulously, linking them to specific part IDs and experimental groups.

5. Annealing Procedure

  • Experimental Groups:

    • Control Group 1 (Air Annealing): Parts annealed in the oven without any support medium.

    • Experimental Group (Green Sand): Parts fully embedded and supported by "Green Sand" within a container (e.g., a metal tray) inside the oven. Ensure the sand is packed consistently around the parts.

    • Control Group 2 (Other Media - Optional): Parts embedded in granular salt or talcum powder for comparison.

  • Temperature Profile:

    • Ramp-up: Gradually increase the oven temperature to the annealing temperature. The rate of increase should be slow enough to prevent thermal shock (e.g., 5-10°C per minute).

    • Soak Time: Maintain the annealing temperature for a specific duration (e.g., 2-4 hours, determined by the PC grade and part thickness).

    • Cool-down: Slowly decrease the oven temperature to room temperature. This is critical for preventing residual stress and warping. The cooling rate should be controlled and gradual (e.g., 1-2°C per minute) and kept consistent across all groups.

  • Annealing Temperature: Select an annealing temperature appropriate for the specific PC filament, typically just below its glass transition temperature (Tg). Consult the filament manufacturer's datasheet. For example, for general PC, this might be 120-150°C.

6. Post-Annealing Measurements

  • Clean Parts: Carefully remove parts from the annealing media and clean any residue.

  • Post-Annealing Data: Measure the same dimensions on each part that were measured pre-annealing.

  • Visual Inspection: Conduct a visual inspection for obvious warping, cracks, or other deformations.

7. Data Analysis

  • Calculate Dimensional Change: For each measured dimension, calculate the percentage change:

    $$\text{% Change} = \frac{(\text{Post-Annealing Measurement} - \text{Pre-Annealing Measurement})}{\text{Pre-Annealing Measurement}} \times 100$$

  • Statistical Analysis:

    • Descriptive Statistics: Calculate mean, median, standard deviation, and range for dimensional changes within each experimental group.

    • Inferential Statistics: Perform appropriate statistical tests (e.g., ANOVA or t-tests) to compare the mean dimensional changes between the "Green Sand" group and the control groups. This will determine if any observed differences are statistically significant.

    • Regression Analysis (Optional): If various part geometries or sizes are used, analyze if dimensional stability correlates with specific features or volumes.

  • Qualitative Analysis: Analyze visual inspection notes for trends in deformation.

Expected Outcomes & Interpretation

  • Support for Hypothesis: If the "Green Sand" group shows significantly less dimensional change (closer to 0% change) and fewer visible deformations compared to the air-annealed control group, the hypothesis would be supported.

  • Refutation of Hypothesis: If there's no significant difference, or if "Green Sand" performs worse, the hypothesis would be rejected.

  • Comparison with Other Media: If other support media are used, their performance can be compared to "Green Sand" to determine its relative effectiveness.

Potential Challenges and Mitigations

  • Moisture in Green Sand: Ensure the moisture content of the "Green Sand" is stable and controlled, as excess moisture could potentially affect the annealing process or the PC part.

  • Sand Particle Size: Consistent sand particle size and composition are crucial for uniform support.

  • Part Removal: Develop a gentle method for removing parts from the sand to avoid damage.

  • Oven Temperature Uniformity: Verify that the annealing oven maintains a consistent temperature throughout its chamber. Use multiple thermocouples if necessary to map the temperature profile.

  • PC Filament Consistency: Variations in filament batch can introduce variability. Use filament from a single batch for all samples.

This section is my edited version of the above testing protocol.
Hypothesis

Green sand will provide increased stability to the annealing of 3D printed polycarbonate parts when compared to other stabilizing methods for the annealing process.

Materials

  • 3D Printer: Prusa Mk3s+ (visible MMU3 not in use for these tests)

  • Polycarbonate Filament: Polymaker PolyLite PolyCarbonate filament in transparent color

  • Green Sand: Petrobond Green Sand

  • Annealing Oven: DIY Annealing enclosure

  • Measurement Tools:

    • High-precision Digital Calipers: For measuring part dimensions before and after annealing ( mm accuracy).

    • Micrometer: For finer measurements if necessary ( mm accuracy).

    • 3D Scanner (Optional but Recommended): For comprehensive dimensional analysis of complex geometries, providing a more complete picture of warping or deformation.

  • Control Media (Optional but Recommended for Comparison):

    • Air (No support): Standard annealing without any support.

    • Granular Salt: A common alternative support medium.

    • Talcum Powder: Another potential alternative.

No comments to display

Back to top